The US Supreme Court on Monday handed the Trump administration a setback, declining to hear its appeal of a ruling that blocked cuts to federal research grants at the University of California — a decision that leaves in place a lower-court finding that the cancellations likely violated the researchers' free-speech rights.
The justices denied review without comment and with no dissents in Trump v. Thakur, leaving intact a ruling by the San Francisco-based 9th US Circuit Court of Appeals. The appeals court had concluded that cancelling the grants likely amounted to unconstitutional viewpoint discrimination, because the funding was cut over the researchers' perceived support for diversity, equity and inclusion.
At stake was about $59 million in grants, according to Reuters, and about $150 million in National Science Foundation and National Endowment for the Humanities grants, according to CNN — part of a wider set of reinstated University of California grants worth hundreds of millions of dollars from the National Institutes of Health, the Defense Department and the Transportation Department.
The case grew out of executive orders signed in January 2025 directing the government to end programs linked to diversity, equity and inclusion. The National Science Foundation and the National Endowment for the Humanities then cut off grants to researchers in the University of California system, one of the world's leading public research institutions. The terminated grants funded projects including efforts to foster discussion about racial equity in science education and to expand science education opportunities for Indigenous youth.
The case is named for UC San Francisco researcher Neeta Thakur, whose $1.3 million Environmental Protection Agency grant studied the effects of wildfire smoke on California communities. Researchers sued in a class action, arguing the cuts punished disfavoured speech. US District Judge Rita Lin halted the terminations, finding the researchers were likely to win their claim, and the 9th Circuit upheld that part of her ruling in May, saying the government "may not use its power to punish or suppress disfavored expression".
The administration's top appellate lawyer, Solicitor General D. John Sauer, had argued the shift was a change in funding priorities that did not implicate the First Amendment, telling the court the First Amendment "does not prohibit the government from declining to award competitive grants that fund research projects that promote DEI". The Supreme Court, which has a 6-3 conservative majority, declined to take the case.
The decision is one of three the court issued on Monday leaving lower-court rulings in place in disputes involving diversity, equity and inclusion — covering federal research grants, medical training and transgender-related speech.
What to watch next: the cases now proceed in the federal district courts, where the researchers' First Amendment claims will be litigated in full — and whether the administration reworks its grant-cutting strategy in light of the ruling.
Sources: Reuters, Nov 16, 2026; CNN, Nov 16, 2026; AP via KSAT, Nov 16, 2026; Los Angeles Times via The Spokesman-Review, Nov 16, 2026; SCOTUSblog, Nov 16, 2026.

No comments:
Post a Comment